Costa Rica vs. Mexico: Which Country Should I Visit on Vacation?

Both Mexico and Costa Rica are some of the most popular tourist destinations in Latin America. While both countries have a lot to offer, each country has its unique flair, culture, attractions, and personality that may lead you to prefer one destination over the other.

While we obviously recommend visiting Costa Rica over Mexico, before you decide to visit Costa Rica vs. Mexico, read through this guide comparing both countries to determine which country is best for you — and then, if you agree with us, book a plane ticket to enjoy the ultimate vacation in Costa Rica!

Weather in Mexico vs. Costa Rica

Mexico and Costa Rica are both known as warm-weather destinations. However, generally speaking, Mexico offers a dry, arid climate, while Costa Rica is more tropical.

Mexico

Mexico is a large country, which means it has several regions and climates — similar to how you’d find differing areas and environments throughout the United States. Before planning a trip to Mexico, it’s essential to check the weather — certain regions will have more favorable temperatures at different times.

Mexico is a large country with a more varied climate than Costa Rica.

For example, drier regions like Baja California, where you find Los Cabos, tend to experience warm winters and hot summers and only receive ten inches of rainfall per year. On the other hand, the Yucatan Peninsula, where you’ll find the Riviera Maya, experiences more rain and, therefore, a tropical, humid climate, with a hurricane season from June to November. Regions in Central Mexico, like San Miguel de Allende or Mexico City, get cold in the winter months of December and January, with low temperatures averaging around 42°F.

Costa Rica

Overall, Costa Rica experiences more consistent weather than Mexico since the country has a tropical climate with two seasons. In Costa Rica, the rainy season lasts from May to November, and the dry season lasts from December to April.

Costa Rica experiences two seasons: a dry season with lots of sunshine and a rainy season with cooler temperatures and significant rainfall.

Though certain regions experience more rain and slight variations in temperatures — for example, the Guanacaste Province is drier and warmer, while the Central Valley and the capital city, San José, are generally wetter and cooler — you can count on consistently good weather when visiting Costa Rica during December through April. The rainiest months in Costa Rica (and the least popular months to visit) are September and October.

Beaches in Costa Rica vs. Mexico

People go to Mexico and Costa Rica for the stunning beaches, so you can’t go wrong with either of these countries for a beach vacation. Here is an overview of the famous beach destinations in Costa Rica and Mexico to see how each compares.

Mexico

Mexico is well-known for its all-inclusive resorts on beautiful beaches on both sides of the country. People who visit Mexico tend to choose one resort community and will stay there for the duration of their vacation. Staying in a popular, well-developed tourist destination, like these resort communities, is also a great way to stay safe from violent crime caused by the drug cartels in Mexico.

The popular beaches in Mexico, like Playa del Carmen and Cancún, tend to be centered around resort communities.

Los Cabos, located in Baja California Sur, is famous for its stunning views, dramatic cliffs, and excellent fishing. Playa del Carmen and Cancún are known for fluffy white sands, turquoise waters, and fun activities like snorkeling and diving. Puerto Vallarta is ideal for surfers, sunbathers, and the nightlife scene.

Costa Rica

Costa Rica’s beaches are on both the Pacific Ocean and along the Caribbean Sea, but most of the country’s beautiful (and most visited) beaches are on the Pacific Coast.

Costa Rica has two coasts, the Pacific and Caribbean Coast, offering gorgeous and unique beaches.

Compared to what you’ll find in Mexico, Costa Rica offers calmer and more laid-back beach towns instead of highly-developed resort communities. Some of the most popular beaches on Costa Rica’s Pacific side include Playa Flamingo, a gorgeous white-sand beach popular for fishing, snorkeling, and sunbathing, and Playa Tamarindo, a beach well-known for surfing and lively nightlife.

Culture in Costa Rica vs. Mexico

Costa Rica and Mexico both have a rich culture — from food and music to events and celebrations. If you’re unsure whether to go to Mexico vs. Costa Rica, perhaps the unique cultural experiences in each country will help you choose a winner.

Mexico

As you explore Mexico, you’ll discover the country has a rich cultural heritage and a friendly, unhurried pace of life. If you want to dive deep into the country’s culture, visit during one of the popular celebrations, like Cinco de Mayo (Mexico Independence Day) or Dia de los Muertos (Day of the Dead), for a taste of the vibrant culture in Mexico.

Costa Rica

Costa Ricans embrace the “pura vida” lifestyle, which translates to “simple life” or “pure life.” They crave simplicity in all areas of life, which translates heavily into Costa Rican culture — the country values eco-friendliness, peacefulness, and an easygoing lifestyle. Costa Rica has a reputation for being a peaceful nation and doesn’t even have a military — making Costa Rica safer for visitors than Mexico.

Costa Rica loves to celebrate its heritage and identity as a peaceful nation with festive celebrations and parades.

Food in Mexico vs. Costa Rica

The good news about the food in these two countries is you really can’t go wrong with either. They both incorporate the freshest local ingredients, lively combinations of spices and textures, and perfectly balanced dishes.

Mexico

Chances are, you’re already familiar with Mexican culture and Mexican meals, especially if you live in the United States. When you visit Mexico, you can try delicious, authentic, spicy tacos, enchiladas, street food, and other delicious Mexican cuisine, depending on where you are in the country. For example, you’ll find more seafood-focused dishes, like ceviche, in coastal cities like Mazatlan.

There is nothing like authentic Mexican foods in Mexico. The tacos, burritos, and seafood are even more amazing here than back at home.

Costa Rica

One of the best ways to experience the culture of Costa Rica during your vacation is through Costa Rican cuisine. Gallo pinto is a traditional dish served in Costa Rica, made with rice, beans, and spices, and casado is another popular Costa Rican food made with rice, beans, meat, plantains, salad, and a tortilla.

Costa Rican cuisine tends to be healthier and lighter than the food in Mexico, so expect lots of fruit, vegetables, and meats incorporated into meals. Costa Rica is also one of the world’s largest suppliers of coffee, so be sure to try some fresh-brewed coffee while you’re in Costa Rica, too!

Safety in Mexico vs. Costa Rica

The issue of safety in these two countries is very important for tourists to understand. Safety in Mexico and Costa Rica depends on where you are and what you’re doing, with major cities generally being more dangerous than popular beach destinations. Where Mexico has some very serious dangers, Costa Rica tends to win the battle of which country is safer overall.

Mexico

When you talk about Mexico, you need to talk about cartel violence. It is a real thing throughout the country, with certain states and cities much more dangerous than others. While Mexico City is relatively safe compared to border towns and cartel-controlled cities in states like Michoacan and Sinaloa, you need to be aware of your surroundings.

Besides serious drug-related violence, you should always be protective of your valuables. Even historical sites can be hotspots for thieves, so be wary at all times. Overall, though, the country is safe if you stick together and are aware of your surroundings.

Costa Rica

In comparison to other Central American countries, Costa Rica is very safe. Besides some dicey areas in Limon, San José, and other larger cities, the nation prides itself on its safety.

With a focus on eco tourism, beach relaxation, and adventuring through lush rainforests, the government and people of Costa Rica offer pura vida and a welcoming environment. You should still avoid flashing excessive cash or wearing expensive jewelry, just to be on the safe side.

Attractions in Mexico vs. Costa Rica

Both Costa Rica and Mexico offer plenty to do during your vacation to keep you busy for days. However, aside from the beaches, the significant sights in Mexico center around history and architecture, while Costa Rica offers more outdoor adventures and attractions.

Mexico

If you’re looking for a country with a rich history on display — visiting Mexico is probably your best bet.

In addition to gorgeous beaches, Mexico offers dozens of archaeological sites and ancient ruins to explore, such as Chichén Itzá and Teotihuacan. There are also several world-class museums in Mexico, like the National Museum of Anthropology Frida Kahlo Museum, that will expose visitors to the unique history, art, and culture of this popular tourist destination.

Chichén Itzá is one of the most famous Mayan ruins that is worth a visit during a trip to Mexico. Nearby, the beaches of Cancun and Cozumel beckon on the Caribbean coasts are popular destinations. Sayulita, Mazatlan, and Zihuatenejo all offer unique charms. You can fly into Mexico City international Airport, Guadalajara, or several other major airports depending on where you want to visit. Here are some of the top attractions:

• Chichen Itza (Yucatán Peninsula): Chichen Itza is one of the New Seven Wonders of the World and a UNESCO World Heritage site, renowned for its impressive pyramid, El Castillo. This ancient Mayan city offers a glimpse into Mexico’s pre-Columbian history, with preserved temples, ball courts, and sacred cenotes.

• Teotihuacan: Known for the pyramid of the Sun and Moon, Teotihuacan is an ancient city where you can climb the massive pyramids and explore its fascinating ruins. It was one of the largest cities in pre-Aztec Mesoamerica.

• Cenotes (Yucatán Peninsula): The Yucatán is home to stunning cenotes – natural freshwater sinkholes that were sacred to the Mayans. These offer unique opportunities for swimming, snorkeling, and cave exploration.

• Xochimilco (Mexico City): Xochimilco is famous for its colorful, flower-adorned boats that cruise through its canals. It’s a happening, cultural spot to enjoy local food, music, and a scenic environment.

• Pacific Coast (Puerto Vallarta and Cabo San Lucas): Mexico’s Pacific coastline has amazing beaches. Known for water sports, whale watching, and luxury resorts, it’s an ideal destination for relaxation and adventure seekers alike.

Costa Rica

The majority of tourist attractions in Costa Rica center around the country’s stunning natural beauty — from the natural hot springs and active volcanoes to the sandy beaches and lush jungles. In fact, nearly 30% of Costa Rica’s land is protected in national parks, making this country the perfect place to visit for nature enthusiasts and outdoor adventurers.

Costa Rica is filled with gorgeous natural scenery that is the perfect launching pad for outdoor excursions and adventures like ziplining, hiking, and white-water rafting.

One of the most popular national parks in Costa Rica is Manuel Antonio National Park, where visitors can spot wildlife, like monkeys, and spend time hiking in the rainforest or surfing on Manuel Antonio Beach. Another famous national park is Monteverde Cloud Forest Reserve, where visitors can enjoy fun activities, like canopy tours and ziplining while observing hundreds of exotic birds and other creatures native to this unique ecosystem.

Whether you fly into Liberia airport or San Jose, you’re near the action. Some of Costa Rica’s attractions include:

• Arenal Volcano National Park: Arenal volcano is one of Costa Rica’s most famous and active volcanoes, surrounded by lush rainforests. You can enjoy hiking, hot springs, and breathtaking views of the conical peak.

• Manuel Antonio National Park: This small but biodiverse park is known for its pristine beaches, amazing wildlife, and tropical rainforest. Visitors can hike its trails, spot monkeys and sloths, and relax by the Pacific.

• Tortuguero National Park: Accessible only by boat or plane, Tortoguero is a remote paradise for wildlife lovers. Its renowned for its canals, biodiversity, and as a nesting site for sea turtles.

• Corcovado National Park: Located on the Osa Peninsula, Corcovado is one of the most biodiverse places on Earth. It offers rugged hikes, abundant wildlife, and pristine beaches, a true haven for nature lovers.

Stay with Special Places of Costa Rica for the Ultimate Vacation Experience

Though Mexico and Costa Rica are both excellent Central American countries to visit, which vacation destination is best for you is a decision only you can make. However, in our opinion, when it boils down to Mexico or Costa Rica — we think Costa Rica is superior because of its unique natural attractions, stunning beaches, exotic wildlife, and reliable weather.

If you’d like to travel to Costa Rica, we hope you’ll consider staying with us at Special Places of Costa Rica. We offer hundreds of vacation rentals, from spacious beachfront homes to luxurious private villas, to help you find the ideal place to stay in Guanacaste, Costa Rica.

Browse our vacation rentals in Costa Rica to find the perfect “home away from home,” and contact us with any questions in the meantime.

FAQs About Costa Rica vs. Mexico

Is Costa Rica cheaper than Mexico?

Generally, Costa Rica is often more expensive than Mexico, particularly when it comes to accommodation, dining, and activities in popular tourist areas. While both countries have budget options, the eco-tourism of Costa Rica and remote destinations drive up costs, especially for tours and transportation.

Is Costa Rica or Mexico better?

Both countries are amazing destinations, but Costa Rica is ideal for nature lovers and adventure seekers, offering lush rainforests, volcanoes, and diverse wildlife. Its focus on sustainable tourism and outdoor activities like hiking, ziplining, horseback riding, and wildlife watching makes it a top choice for those wanting an immersive natural experience.

Is Mexico or Costa Rica safer?

Costa Rica is generally considered safer than Mexico, particularly for tourists. While both countries have areas that are very safe and others with higher crime rates, Costa Rica tends to have lower levels of violent crime, especially in popular tourist areas.